Home of Genuine Products | Installments available for Govt Employees
Genuine products | Easy installments for Govt Employees

Instant Geyser vs Storage Geyser: Which Is Better?

Instant Geyser vs Storage Geyser: Which Is Better? - SK Electronics buying guide

Quick answer: An instant geyser heats water only while it flows, so it wastes almost no gas when nobody is using hot water, and it is the cheaper unit to buy. A storage geyser keeps a tank of water hot, so several taps can run at once and you still have hot water if the gas pressure drops for a while. For one bathroom or one kitchen, an instant geyser is usually the better buy. For a big family with several bathrooms in use on winter mornings, a storage geyser is usually the safer choice.

What is the difference between an instant and a storage geyser?

An instant geyser (also called a tankless or on-demand water heater) has no tank. A guide from the US Department of Energy’s Building America Solution Center explains that a sensor detects water flow and starts the burner, which heats the water as it passes through. When you close the tap, the burner stops.

A storage geyser has an insulated tank. The burner or electric element heats the full tank and keeps it hot, so hot water is ready the moment you open a tap, and several taps can draw from the tank at once.

We sell both types from Nasgas: the Nasgas DG-06L Crystal and Nasgas DG-7L instant geysers, and the Nasgas DEG-35 Super Deluxe storage heater, which runs on gas and also has a 3.0 kW electric element.

Nasgas DG-06L Crystal instant gas water heater with digital temperature display
Nasgas DG-06L Crystal: an instant gas geyser rated at 6 litres per minute.

Instant vs storage geyser: side by side

Point Instant geyser Storage geyser
How it heats Only while water flows Keeps a full tank hot
Gas wasted while idle Almost none (no tank to keep hot) Some heat is lost from the tank all day
Hot water at several taps at once Limited by the flow rate Yes, until the tank runs down
When gas pressure drops Water turns lukewarm straight away The stored hot water lasts a while; the DEG-35 can also heat on electricity
Space Small, wall-mounted Large tank
Our models Nasgas DG-06L (6 L/min), DG-7L (7 L/min) Nasgas DEG-35 Super Deluxe
Price at the time of writing Rs 19,499 to Rs 19,999 Rs 49,999

Prices change with the market, so call 0333-9080484 or WhatsApp 0348-7647331 to confirm before you buy.

How much hot water can an instant geyser give?

An instant geyser is rated in litres per minute. The DG-06L is rated at 6 litres per minute and the DG-7L at 7 litres per minute. That is the flow it can heat at one time, and the Building America guide warns that there is a limit to the volume of hot water available at any given time: if several taps run at once, the water may not be as hot as you want.

Here is the physics behind that limit. Heating 1 litre of water by 1°C takes about 4.19 kJ of energy. So the heater power needed is:

Power (kW) = litres per minute x temperature rise (°C) x 0.07

Flow Rise of 20°C Rise of 25°C Rise of 30°C
6 litres per minute 8.4 kW 10.5 kW 12.6 kW
7 litres per minute 9.8 kW 12.2 kW 14.7 kW
Bar chart: an instant geyser needs 8.4 to 12.6 kW at 6 litres per minute and 9.8 to 14.7 kW at 7 litres per minute for a 20 to 30°C temperature rise
Heater power needed by flow rate and temperature rise.

The table shows why the same geyser feels hotter in October than in January. In winter the water entering the geyser is colder, so it needs a bigger rise to reach shower temperature. A burner of fixed size can only give that bigger rise at a lower flow. In practice, on the coldest mornings you may need to open the hot tap a little less to keep the water hot.

Worked example: one family, two choices

Take a family of six with two bathrooms, where two people shower at the same time on winter mornings.

  • With one instant geyser: a 7 litre per minute unit shared by two showers gives each about 3.5 litres per minute. On a cold morning that may feel weak or lukewarm. Two separate instant geysers, one per bathroom, solve this for about the price of one storage heater.
  • With one storage geyser: both showers draw from the hot tank at the same time. When the gas pressure drops, the tank still holds hot water for a while, and the DEG-35 can switch to its 3.0 kW electric element.

How long does a 3.0 kW element take? Heating 100 litres from 15°C to 45°C needs about 3.5 kWh, which is roughly 70 minutes at 3.0 kW, before heat losses, and about 3.5 units on your electricity bill. A bigger tank or a bigger temperature rise takes longer. Ask our team for the tank capacity of the model you choose.

Which geyser saves more gas?

An instant geyser does, when the hot water is used in short bursts. The Building America guide says tankless heaters have almost none of the standby losses that tank water heaters have, because they do not keep a large volume of water hot. A storage geyser keeps reheating its tank to replace the heat that leaks through the insulation, even at night.

A storage geyser can still make sense when hot water is used heavily through the day, or where the gas supply is unreliable and you value a reserve of hot water over the lowest gas use.

Is a gas geyser safe? Installation rules that matter

Every gas geyser burns fuel, and burning fuel makes carbon monoxide (CO), a gas you cannot see or smell. The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) lists headache, dizziness, weakness and upset stomach as the most common symptoms, and warns that a lot of CO can make you pass out or kill you. Follow these points for any gas geyser:

  • Vent it to the outside. The CDC says gas appliances must be vented properly, and horizontal vent pipes from a water heater should rise slightly as they go towards the outdoors.
  • Do not fit a gas geyser inside a closed bathroom without a flue to the outside. The Building America guide strongly recommends sealed combustion units, which take air from outdoors and exhaust outdoors.
  • Use a qualified installer and have the geyser serviced every year, as the CDC advises for gas appliances.
  • Fit a CO detector with a battery near the bedrooms. The CDC recommends one near every sleeping area.

Our instant geysers include their own safety features: the DG-06L has auto cut-off with anti-freeze and dry burn protection, and the DG-7L has auto safety cut-off and anti-freezing protection. These do not replace proper venting.

Which one should you buy?

  • Choose an instant geyser if hot water goes to one bathroom or one kitchen, you want lower gas use and a lower price, and you have space only on the wall. Pick the 7 litre DG-7L if you want a little more flow.
  • Choose a storage geyser if two or more bathrooms run at once, your gas pressure often falls in winter, or you want electric backup. The DEG-35 runs on gas and on its 3.0 kW element.
  • Consider two instant geysers instead of one big storage unit when the bathrooms are far apart. Each bathroom gets its own full flow, and you avoid long pipe runs where hot water cools down.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, an instant geyser or a storage geyser?

An instant geyser is better for one bathroom or kitchen and for saving gas, because it heats only while water flows. A storage geyser is better when several taps run at once or when gas pressure is unreliable, because it keeps a tank of hot water ready.

Does an instant geyser work when gas pressure is low?

It needs gas to heat the water while it flows, so when the pressure drops the water gets cooler straight away. A storage geyser keeps hot water in its tank for a while, and a gas and electric model such as the Nasgas DEG-35 can heat on electricity.

Can two showers run on one instant geyser?

They can, but they share its flow. A 7 litre per minute geyser gives each shower about 3.5 litres per minute, which can feel lukewarm on cold mornings. One instant geyser per bathroom works better.

How many electricity units does a 3 kW electric geyser use?

A 3 kW element uses 3 units for every hour it runs. Heating 100 litres by 30°C needs about 3.5 units before heat losses.

Can I install a gas geyser inside the bathroom?

Only if it is vented to the outside by a qualified installer. Burning gas makes carbon monoxide, and the CDC says gas appliances must be vented properly. Fit a CO detector near sleeping areas as well.

Next steps

Compare the models in our geysers range, or visit any branch in Risalpur, Nowshera Kalan, Kheshgi Chungi or Rashakai to see them. Planning a winter upgrade? A heat and cool inverter AC can also warm a room in winter; see how many units a 1.5 ton inverter AC uses. For more help, browse all our buying guides.

Also read: electric geyser vs gas geyser.

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Cookies on SK Electronics

We use essential cookies to run the shop, such as your cart and login. With your permission we also use Google Analytics to see how the site is used, so we can improve it. You can change your choice at any time under Cookie settings at the bottom of the page. Privacy Policy